Loading... Please wait...


Our Newsletter


Tag Cloud

Refined browsing for people who are shopping for related items.

1826 Ink Cartridge Clip Canon BC02 BX3  1827  1827 Inkjet Cartridge Transport clip Canon BC20 22 23 29  5022 Ink Cartridge Clip Lexmark 23A 24A 25 28A 29A 32 33 34 35 41A 42A 43 44 82 83 88 dell 7Y743 J55  6025 Ink Cartridge Clip HP 21 28 56 57 60 61 100 101 94 95 96 97 98  6025 Ink Cartridge Clip HP 21 28 56 57 60 61 100 101 94 95 96 97 98 Universal Cartridge Clip  6026 Ink Cartridge Clip Lexmark 20 50 55 60 70 75  6027 Ink Cartridge Clip Lexmark 10N16 17 26 17  6103  6103 Ink Cartridge Clip HP 15 45 C8842  6109 Ink Cartridge Clip HP 51625 25 26 29 49  6967  6967 - Narrow Pad for Clip  9978 Ink Cartridge Clip HP 78 HP23 HP17  Air Bubble Eliminator  All Ink Cartridge 'PULL' Red Label  Aspen Black Dye Ink Canon CLI 226 Tank Cartridge  Bags  Bags and Boxes  Black Ink  Black Label Cover for HP 15 and 45 Ink Cartridge  Boxes  Boxes & Bags  Brother LC41  Canon  Canon 220  Canon 221  Canon 225  Canon 226  Canon 30  Canon 40  Canon 50  Canon BC02  Canon BC20  Canon BC22  Canon BC23  Canon BC29  Canon BCI3  Canon BX3  Canon CL  Canon CL 31  Canon CL 41  Canon CL 51  Canon CL 52  Canon CL211  Canon CLI221  Canon CLI226  Canon CLI8  Canon PG 37  Canon PG 40  Canon PG-30  Canon PG-40  Canon PG-50  Canon PG/cli  Canon PG210  Canon PGI220  Canon PGI225  Canon PGI5  Caps  Caps & Plugs  cartridge clip  Cleaning Solutions  clip pads  clips  compressor oil  Cyan HP Ink  Cyan Ink  Dell  Dell 7Y743  Dell 7y743 Black  Dell 7y745 Color  Dell J5556  Dell M4640 Black  Dell M4646 Color  Dell TO529 Black  Dell TO529 Color  Dell TO530 Color  Dye Ink  for filling 10 11 88 940 cartridges  Four station  HP  HP 10  HP 100  HP 101  HP 1011  HP 11  HP 15  HP 15 and 45  HP 17  HP 20  HP 21  HP 22  HP 23  HP 25  HP 25A  HP 26  HP 28  HP 29  HP 41  HP 45  HP 49  HP 50  HP 51625  HP 51641  HP 56  HP 564  HP 57  HP 60  HP 61  HP 74  HP 74 and 96  HP 74XL  HP 75  HP 78  HP 88  HP 90  HP 901  HP 920  HP 94  HP 940  HP 95  HP 95 Ink Cartridge Label  HP 9597  HP 96  HP 97  HP 97 Ink Cartridge Label  HP 98  HP 99  HP 99 Ink Cartridge Label  HP C1823  HP C1823 Ink Cartridge Label  HP C6578  HP C6578 Ink Cartridge Label  HP C6614  HP C6614 Ink Cartridge Label  HP C6615  HP C6615 Ink Cartridge Label  HP C6625  HP C6625 Ink Cartridge Label  HP C6656  HP C6656 Ink Cartridge Label  HP C6657 Ink Cartridge Label  HP C6658  HP C6658 Photo Ink Cartridge Label  HP C8842  HP Soaking Solution  HP15  HPL C6657  Impulse Bag Sealer  Impulse Sealer  Ink  Ink & Cleaning Solutions  Ink Cartridge Chip Resetter for Canon PGI220 and Canon CLI221  Ink Cartridge Chip Resetter for Canon PGI225 and Canon CLI226  Ink Cartridge Cleaning Machines  ink cartridge clip  Ink Cartridge Clip Canon PG-30 40 50 CL 31 41 51 52  Ink Cartridge Clip Canon PG210 CL211  Ink Cartridge Clip HP 15 45 "Silver Plastic Color"  Ink Cartridge Ink Inlet Hole Ball Plug for HP 1011 88 940 Canon CLI8  Ink Cartridge Ink Inlet Hole Rubber Plug for Canon PGI5 CLI8 220 221 225 226 HP 564 920  Ink Cartridge Print head Air Bubble Eliminator for HP 21 22 56 57 95 97 60 901 size cartridge  Ink Cartridge Print head Air Bubble Eliminator for Dell - Lexmark 16 17 27  Ink Cartridge Print head Air Bubble Eliminator for Dell - Lexmark 31 32 33 Canon PG 37 40 Ink Cartr  Ink Cartridge Print head Air Bubble Eliminator for HP 74XL and 96  Ink Cartridge Printhead Nozzle Cleaner  Ink Cartridge Printhead Nozzle Cleaner Flush Tool for HP black and color low profile cartridges  ink cartridge recycling centrifuge  ink cartridge recycling spinner  Ink Cartridge Refill Tool - Four Station Canon BCI3 PGI5 CLI8 Ink Cartridges  Ink Cartridge Refill Tool for Brother LC41 Cartridges  Ink Cartridge Refill Tool for HP 564 920 Canon BCI3 PGI5 CLI8 Ink Cartridges  Ink Cartridge Refilling Machines  Ink Cartridge Remanufacturing Supplies  Ink Cartridge Remanufacturings Supplies  ink cartridge transport cartridge clip  Ink cartridge transport clip  Ink Cartridge Vent Hole Plug for HP 78 23 41  Ink Cartridges  Ink Ink cartridge transport clip  inkjet  inkjet cartridge clip  inkjet cartridge spinner  Inkjet Filling and Cleaning  jun air  jun air compressor oil  Jun-Air  labels  Lexmark  Lexmark 1  Lexmark 10N  Lexmark 10N0016  Lexmark 10N0026  Lexmark 10N16  Lexmark 10N26 - 32  Lexmark 12A  Lexmark 12A1980  Lexmark 15  Lexmark 15M0120  Lexmark 15m120  Lexmark 16  Lexmark 16 Ink Cartridge Label  Lexmark 17  Lexmark 17G0050  Lexmark 17G0050 Ink Cartridge Label  Lexmark 17G0060  Lexmark 17G0060 Ink Cartridge Label  Lexmark 20  Lexmark 23A  Lexmark 24A  Lexmark 25  Lexmark 26  Lexmark 26 Ink Cartridge Label  Lexmark 27  Lexmark 28A  Lexmark 29A  Lexmark 30  Lexmark 31  Lexmark 32  Lexmark 33  Lexmark 34  Lexmark 35  Lexmark 41A  Lexmark 42A  Lexmark 43  Lexmark 44  Lexmark 50  Lexmark 55  Lexmark 60  Lexmark 70  Lexmark 75  Lexmark 82  Lexmark 82 Ink Cartridge Label  Lexmark 83  Lexmark 83 Ink Cartridge Label  Lexmark 88  Lexmark Plugbuster Soaking Solution  Magenta Ink  Narrow Pad for Ink Cartridge Clips  Needle  Needle Blunt 1.5" 18 gauge  Needle blunt 1/2"  Orange Ink Cartridge Printhead Tape Canon Cartridges 3/4" x 60 yds  Paper  Paper Roll- Large (500')  Paper Rolls (small)  Pigmented Ink  Plastic  Plastic Syringe Tip  Plug for Ink Inlet Hole-vent on HP 78 C1823 51641  Plugs  Poly 3" x 5" Bag  Poly 4" x 6'' Bag  Print head Air Bubble Eliminator  ReDuRan Special Hand Cleaner  Replacement Cap Dell 7y743 Black  Replacement Cap Dell 7y745 Color  Replacement Cap Dell M4640 Black  Replacement Cap Dell M4646 Color  Replacement Cap Dell TO529 Black  Replacement Cap Dell TO530 Color  Replacement Cap HP 25A  Replacement Cap Lexmark 10N0016  Replacement Cap Lexmark 10N0026  Replacement Cap Lexmark 17G0050  Replacement Cap Lexmark 17G0060  Replacement Cap Lexmark 30 Series  Replacement Cap Lexmark 82  Replacement Cap Lexmark 83  Replacement Cap Sharp S-16  Replacment Cap Lexmark 12A1980  Rubber Stem Bumper Stem Plug  sharp 1" 18 gauge Needle  Sharp 4" 22 gauge Needle  Sharp S-16  sil air compressor oil  Sil-Air  silent compressor oil  sj-27 compressor oil  sj-27 oil  sj-27F  sj27 silent compressor oil  Sponge Reset Tool for HP 50-90  Sponge Reset Tool for HP 74 and 96  Sponge Reset Tool for Lexmark 15m0120  Sponge Reset Tool for Lexmark 26/32  Sponge Reset Tool Set of 4 for HP Lexmark Dell cartridges  Stainless Steel Ball Plug for HP 15 and 45  Static Shielding Bag  Static Shielding ESD Zip-Lock Bag 4' x 6"  Static Shielding Open End Bag 3 x 5  Static Shielding Open End Bag 4 x 6  Supplies  synthetic compressor oil  Synthetic Oil  Syringe  Syringe Tip  Syringe with luer lock 60cc non- sterile  Syringe with luer lock 10cc non- sterile  Syringe with luer lock 140 cc non- sterile  Syringe with luer lock 20cc non- sterile  Tape  Tape Dispenser  Tape Dispenser Adjustable Length  TrueColor Black Pigmented Broad Application Ink  TrueColor Cyan Ink  TrueColor Magenta Ink  TrueColor Yellow Ink  Universal Cap Lexmark 16/ Dell TO529 Color  Universal Cap Lexmark 26/ Dell TO530 Color  Universal Cap Lexmark 83/ Dell 7y745 Color  Universal HP Ink Cartridge Clip  White Ink Cartridge Box for HP 15 and 45 Size cartridges  White Ink Cartridge Box for HP 23 78 Lexmark 12A 15 16 Size cartridges  White Ink Cartridge Box for low profile HP 56 9597 lexmark 10N 1 31 Canon PG/cli 30 40 50 cartridges  Yellow Ink  
Advanced Search | Search Tips

August 13, 2009: Article, Inkjet - "Damn the Torpedoes,..."

Thursday, August 13, 2009

“Damn the Torpedoes, Full Speed Ahead”
By Allen Luthy, SME, Inc. (CBR-SME)

Published September 2005, Imaging Spectrum Magazine

On August 5, 1864, Rear Admiral David Farragut, bravely sailed with his fleet of 18 ships into battle to attempt to capture the heavily-guarded port of Mobile, Ala., the Confederacy’s last major seaport which was open on the Gulf of Mexico. During the heated exchange of cannon fire between the ships and the batteries onshore, one of Farragut’s ships exploded after encountering a tethered naval mine (at the time these were called “torpedoes”).   Immediately, several ships of the small fleet began to turn back for fear of meeting the same fate, and the attack appeared to stall. At that critical moment, one of America’s most underrated naval heroes, Admiral Farragut, shouted the order, “Damn the torpedoes, full speed ahead!” With that, the fleet pressed on with the attack, and eventually all 17 of the remaining ships sailed through the channel. Shortly thereafter, Mobile Bay’s forts fell.

Waging an All-out Battle

Currently there is an all-out battle between the OEMs and the inkjet remanufacturing industry for the hearts and minds of the consumer, and Admiral Farragut’s immortal words are just as relevant for our industry today as they were 141 years ago. Earlier this year, Hewlett-Packard (HP) commissioned Quality Logic (an independent test laboratory in Moorpark, Calif.) to compare new HP inkjet cartridges to cartridges that were refilled by two inkjet refill chains in California. The Quality Logic report’s “objective” results were clearly predictable: New HP OEM cartridges were far superior to the “unreliable” remanufactured inkjet cartridges. (See the article “False Assumptions, Faulty Logic Pervade New HP Environmental Report” in the February 2004 issue of Imaging Spectrum.)

This was not the first shot fired across the bow of the remanufacturing industry. Lexmark’s over-reaching, soap opera, litigation frenzy, RadioShack’s in-store displays that inaccurately portrayed that printer warranties “will be voided by using remanufactured cartridges”—in clear violation of the Magnussun Moss Warranty Act—(See The Last Word in the October 2004 and December 2004 issues of Imaging Spectrum for details on the RadioShack display), and HP’s product differentiation advertisements highlighting its nearly century-long, archival-quality Vivera inks are just a few of the vehicles that the OEMs are using to influence consumer purchasing behaviors.

Wild-fire Inkjet Expansion

During the 1990s, the total share of aftermarket inkjet cartridges was relatively insignificant in relation to the total number of cartridges shipped. However, today that number is 18 percent of the total inkjet market and, according to Lyra Research’s second half of 2004 report, is expected to continue to rise over the course of the next several years.

This tremendous growth is especially prevalent in the retail store-front arena where customers are really attracted to a local brick-and-mortar establishment. One large retail cartridge franchise chain claims a new store opening every 17 hours, another trumpets a 600 percent growth in 2004-2005, while yet a third actually had to stop selling franchises altogether while its infrastructure rushed to keep up with the demand. This nearly exponential growth is a significant cause for concern for the OEMs. With more than 56 percent of the U.S. population that have never even purchased a remanufactured cartridge, now is the critical time to define our industry. 

Inconsistent Quality, Negative Reports

Although many of the worldwide inkjet remanufacturers use reliable multi-step processes, sophisticated professional cleaning and filling equipment, and adhere to rigorous quality standards, unfortunately there are a handful of others that purvey substandard products which negatively impact the entire industry. Some of the major culprits are the messy and unreliable home inkjet refill kits, “compatible” cartridges that use substandard inks and shady Internet opportunists that prey on the naïve consumer. All have historically offered marginal results at best and, in many cases, have contributed to a long-standing negative perception of cartridge remanufacturing in general. Consumer Reports analyzed some of these product offerings in 2004 and rated them poorly.

The traditional method of refilling of inkjet cartridges by hand (using a syringe to inject ink into the cartridge) worked effectively several years ago, but not today. Most of the new inkjet cartridges that entered the market after 2001 use polyurethane foams to help to meter the ink inside the cartridge. If these foam cartridges are filled by syringe and not in a true vacuum chamber (just as the OEM fills the cartridge), a high percentage of these cartridges will suffer from ink starvation and will fail prematurely. Unfortunately, many of the early industry pioneers neglected to keep current with the ever-changing requirements for processing the more advanced and sophisticated cartridges entering the market. 

Apparently selling $150K+ franchises is easy in this “gold rush” environment, but ensuring uniformly high success rates throughout the entire organization is not. Although some franchisers offer excellent turnkey solutions and world-class support, at least one large franchise chain still uses syringes for refilling in many locations. Was it purely coincidence that this particular franchiser was one of two that were targeted specifically by HP and Quality Logic for their cartridge comparison testing? Hardly. These results were used to paint the entire industry in a negative light.

The same situation applies to the highly-skewed testing protocol that Quality Logic used to compare new HP cartridges to remanufactured ones. Most consumers are willing to accept minor print flaws (most of which are not even visible to the naked eye), in order to save $15 or more per cartridge. If there is a nozzle failure, and customers are printing photographs, they can mask most print flaws by merely changing the default print setting on their printer to “best” print quality, which is usually the preferred mode for photos anyway. The complex dithering algorithms of the print cartridge overlap ink droplets that saturate the printing area to deliver a rich and vibrant print. However, the consumer will not know this without some written or verbal consumer education.

Educating the Consumer

An interesting dynamic is occurring with the advent of a new generation of in-store cartridge refilling systems. Historically, the paradigm was that most industrial and retail refilling operations refilled inkjet cartridges off-site or in a back room— away from the customer.  Remanufacturing cartridges is a time-consuming, messy business that requires many process steps and numerous pieces of equipment. The consumer would purchase pre-packaged, finished goods, and there was little opportunity to discuss specific cartridge performance characteristics (i.e. full-page print test analysis of the remanufactured cartridge).  

The excitement with these new systems focuses upon their ability to perform quality cartridge remanufacturing in just a matter of minutes, while the customer waits. Certainly there are many consumers that purchase for convenience. They want to purchase a replacement cartridge and leave, while there are others that do not mind waiting a few minutes for their specific cartridge to be refilled. Having the consumer in the store for an extended time is attractive for retailers, because it generally leads to an increased average total sale (customers purchase ancillary products) as well as becoming an excellent venue for both passive and active consumer education to positively influence the purchasing decision.

Common passive consumer media consist of informative labeling, product literature and in-store signage—all of which convey a wealth of information about product, guarantees, recycling, the company, etc.  These tools are valuable but not always effective (not absorbed by the consumer). Active consumer education is probably the most effective tool for influencing both a consumer’s purchase as well as preventing any post-sale cognitive dissonance (buyer’s remorse) issues.

Just Two Minutes

An initial two-minute dialog with a customer is not always feasible, but it has several obvious benefits:

  1. Providing an overview of the remanufacturing process helps to illuminate the value proposition, dispel any perceived risk notions and highlight the benefits of recycling.
  2. This time can be used to help customers better understand simple cartridge dynamics, which is especially helpful for repeat business. Such points include not printing the cartridge dry (thereby burning out the cartridge heating elements), clipping the cartridge during transportation, keeping the print head fresh and so on.
  3. The differences in print media can be reviewed. The print quality of a remanufactured cartridge should be comparable to the OEM on equivalent paper (standard, glossy, photo). In fact, one retailer mentioned that when asked to select which print sample was made using the aftermarket cartridge and which one was printed using the OEM cartridge on the same paper and printer, 50 percent selected the aftermarket cartridge.  This also increases the chances for an up-sell of premium print media concurrent with the refill transaction. In retail situations, the customer’s specific cartridge can be tested in front of the customer in either a full-page printer or print tester.
  4. Finally, this rapport-building time with the customer also may lead to constructive dialog if a cartridge actually does fail prematurely in the field. Often customers do not bother to return a failed cartridge—it is just not worth the time or effort. For example, many people have purchased a home inkjet refill kit once. The experience was usually not positive and the “defective” product was not returned to the store for a refund. Generally, a seller gets only one chance to make a good first impression.

Developing Inkjet Standards

One reason that growth in the inkjet remanufacturing industry remains strong is that many remanufacturers are doing an exemplary job of producing the highest quality products.  However, the most pressing issue that plagues the entire inkjet remanufacturing industry is that there are no established universally-accepted quality standards. Ten years ago, the remanufactured laser and toner industry had many of the same challenges. Over time, standards were established and adopted (for example, the Standardized Test Methods Committee (STMC)), and gradually the cartridge quality and industry reputation improved dramatically. This occurred to such an extent that many large states like California, Texas and New York actually now give preference to remanufactured cartridges over new OEM cartridges because of reliability and cost savings. Finally, the inkjet industry is following the same blue print.

Consumer education regarding inkjet remanufacturing is a critical component in our industry’s success. Industry awareness about our marketplace is still not universal, and we can still shape consumers’ perception about the quality of our products. Without agreeing to adopt recognized industry quality standards, the industry will continue to be plagued by substandard products that will negatively impact our entire industry.

Marcel Kunz, president of Recharge Technologies International and chairman of the STMC Subcommittee for Inkjet, said, “As a collective group, we must press hard to establish and adopt quality standards for inkjet cartridges. The current members of the STMC inkjet subcommittee, representing a diverse group of international remanufacturers and suppliers, is finally doing just that and making good progress. After the standardized testing methods are adopted, guidelines for certification will be established. All vendors will need to conform in order to earn the certification, which will bring the industry a huge step forward. Without these standards, we are like a rudderless ship without direction.”

Spreading the Word about Quality

We should expect that the OEMs will continue to attempt to sway the consumer away from remanufactured cartridges, using misleading reports or negative advertisements. By policing our own industry, providing our customers with a quality product and fighting for our own reputation and legitimacy, we can persevere through adversity—much like Admiral Farragut’s fleet during the Battle of Mobile Bay—and win this consumer education war.

Photo Caption: Clay Cutler of Cartridge Central (2005) holds up comparison photos of an OEM print versus a remanufactured print. Fifty percent of consumers select the aftermarket print instead of the OEM.


   Full Name:
*  Email Address:
   Company Name:
   Phone Number:
   Order Number:
   RMA Number:
*  Details:
*  Captcha Check:

Please copy the characters from the image into the text field below. Doing this helps us prevent automated submissions.

img